Stop Kissing an Electronic Device After Reading the Gospel in a Liturgical Assembly. You Cannot Consecrate Ambiguity with a Kiss.

Dear Brothers in the Sacred Priesthood and Diaconate,
Peace!

This letter comes from a place of concern, not contention. I have observed with increasing discomfort a practice creeping into our liturgical assemblies: the proclamation of the Gospel from a mobile phone, an iPad, or similar electronic device, and then—to compound the abuse—the kissing of that same device at the end, whilst reciting the formula, Per evangelica dicta, deleantur nostra delicta.

Brothers, we must stop. It is bad enough to read the Gospel from a phone in a liturgical assembly. To kiss that phone afterwards is liturgically indefensible.

1. The Gospel is not proclaimed from a device. It is proclaimed from a Book.

The Church is clear, and she has been consistent on this:

  • General Instruction of the Roman Missal (GIRM) No. 349: Only blessed objects may be placed on the altar. A phone is never blessed for liturgical use.
  • GIRM No. 273 and No. 175: The readings at Mass are to be proclaimed from the Lectionary and the Book of Gospels from the ambo.
  • Redemptionis Sacramentum, No. 117: The practice of replacing liturgical books with “common pastoral aids” is reprobated.

A phone, no matter how expensive, is a common pastoral aid. Worse, it is a profane, multi-purpose object. The same device that now displays John 1:1 also contains a betting app, a pornographic pop-up, a quarrel on WhatsApp, or a bank alert. The liturgical book, by contrast, has one purpose: it is printed, bound, blessed, enthroned, incensed, and reserved for one thing alone—to make Christ present in His Word.

If we cannot proclaim from a liturgical book, we should not proclaim. Convenience should never override reverence.

2. The kiss is not for the text. The kiss is for the sacramental object.

When we kiss the Book after the Gospel, we do not kiss information. We kiss a Person. In the same way, we kiss the altar because the altar is Christ. We kiss the Book of Gospels because, as Sacrosanctum Concilium No. 7 teaches, Christ is present in His Word proclaimed. The Book is a sacramental sign of that presence. That is why it is carried in procession, placed on the altar, incensed, lifted high for the people to see, and kissed.

Let us be clear about this. A phone displays information. The Book of Gospels makes Christ present. We cannot consecrate ambiguity with a kiss. You cannot take an object that serves everything and, by kissing it for three seconds, make it serve only the holy. The faithful are not edified; they are confused. The child in the pew learns that a phone is equal to the Bible. The old woman who cannot read but knows holiness when she sees it sees us trivialize what we claim to reverence.

3. The liturgical action is a chain. You cannot select one link and exclude others.

The veneration of the Gospel is a complete ritual chain: Enthronement on the altar—Incensing—Proclamation from the ambo—Acclamation by the people—Veneration by the kiss. If a device is not worthy to be enthroned on the altar at the beginning of Mass, and not worthy to be incensed before the Gospel, then it is not worthy to be kissed after the Gospel. If you would not incense your phone, do not kiss it.

Brothers, let us return to reverence.

I appeal to you, not as a judge, but as a brother priest who also faces poor sacristies, power failures, and missing books. Yet the solution is not to normalize the abnormal. The solution is to provide the Book. Let every parish have a dignified Lectionary. Let every deanery ensure its churches have a Book of Gospels, even if simple. Let us carry it with reverence. Let us proclaim from it alone.

Our people deserve to see that we still believe what we kiss.

If we must use a phone to prepare the homily in the sacristy, let us do so. But when we step to the ambo for the liturgical proclamation, let us leave the phone in the sacristy and take up the Book.

Fraternally in Christ,
Rev. Fr. Paulinus Ikechukwu Ogara
Director, Religious Education,
Catholic Diocese of Nsukka