A Reflection on Priestly Fraternity, Mutual Respect, Mentorship, Correction, Sensitivity and Ecclesiastical Discipline
“We are all priests, but none of us is the complete embodiment of priestly wisdom. We need one another.”
Introduction: The Commonality of Priesthood and the Reality of Human Differences
One of the beautiful gifts of the Sacrament of Holy Orders is that it brings men of different backgrounds, ages, qualifications, temperaments, talents and experiences into one presbyterium, united by a common vocation and mission. We are all priests, called by Christ, configured to Him and entrusted with continuing His mission of proclaiming the Gospel, sanctifying God’s people and shepherding the Church.
Yet being priests together does not mean that we are all at the same level of maturity, experience, responsibility or competence. Nor does it mean that we share identical gifts, temperaments or approaches to ministry.
This distinction matters today because the assertion “we are all priests” is sometimes misapplied. It is used to justify a false equality that disregards experience, undermines legitimate authority, resists mentorship, dismisses ecclesiastical discipline and makes correction unnecessarily difficult to accept.
The question, therefore, is not whether we are all priests. We are. The more important question is whether we have understood what it means to be priests together. Priestly fraternity is not merely about sharing the same sacrament; it is about cultivating the dispositions that make living, working and ministering together possible.
1. Equality in Priesthood Does Not Mean Sameness in Everything
Some priests interpret our common participation in the priesthood of Christ as though it erased every distinction of age, experience, responsibility and office. This is a misunderstanding.
Ordination confers a sacred ministry; it does not confer instant mastery of pastoral administration, spiritual direction, human relationships, leadership, conflict management or Church governance. A newly ordained priest and a priest of thirty or forty years’ ministry share the same priestly identity, but not the same pastoral experience, institutional memory and practical wisdom. It is unreasonable to suppose that decades of experience carry no value simply because another person has also been ordained.
Equally, seniority must never become an excuse for arrogance or intimidation, or for assuming that older priests cannot learn from younger ones.
The point is simple: equality in priestly dignity should encourage mutual respect; it should not abolish the recognition of experience and responsibility.
2. Personality Differences Should Enrich, Not Destroy, Priestly Fraternity
Priests are human beings with different personalities. Some are outgoing, others reserved. Some are outspoken, others diplomatic. Some are intellectual, others practical. Some are administratively gifted, others especially effective in pastoral relationships.
These differences are part of the richness of our common vocation. Unfortunately, we sometimes expect others to think, speak and act exactly as we do, and when they do not, we label them difficult, arrogant, proud or uncooperative. Maturity recognises that a difference in personality is not necessarily a defect of character.
At the same time, personality must never become an excuse for discourtesy, insubordination or refusal to cooperate. A healthy presbyterium is not one in which everybody thinks alike, but one in which people who think differently can still work together in mutual respect and common purpose.
3. Hierarchy Is About Service and Responsibility, Not Superiority
The Church is not an organisation without structure. She has an established order of authority, responsibility and accountability. The bishop bears particular responsibility for the pastoral governance of the diocese, and priests collaborate with him and with one another. Within the presbyterium there are also differences of office, assignment and responsibility.
These distinctions are not meant to create a class system among priests, nor to become instruments of oppression. Yet the existence of hierarchy must be respected. A priest entrusted with a responsibility must be allowed to exercise it within the limits of his legitimate authority, and he must remain accountable for how he does so.
A subordinate priest should not undermine legitimate authority simply because he disagrees with a decision. A superior should not demand unquestioning personal loyalty where dialogue, explanation and accountability are appropriate. Jesus reminds us:
“Whoever wishes to become great among you must be your servant.” (Matthew 20:26)
Ecclesiastical authority is fundamentally a ministry of service. It must not be confused with privilege, entitlement or superiority. Likewise, obedience is not the surrender of one’s intelligence, conscience or legitimate right to dialogue; it is a virtue exercised within the communion and mission of the Church.
4. The Crisis of Respect Among Priests
One disturbing development is the gradual erosion of mutual respect. Respect is sometimes treated as an entitlement to be demanded rather than a virtue to be demonstrated. Some priests expect others to honour their personalities, opinions and positions, but are not always willing to extend the same courtesy to their confreres. We sometimes encounter situations where:
- A younger priest finds it difficult to acknowledge the experience of an older priest.
- Senior priests use age, position or experience to intimidate rather than mentor.
- A priest interprets advice as interference in his personal affairs.
- A priest takes legitimate correction as an attack on his dignity.
- A priest considers himself beyond reproach because of his academic qualifications, abilities or achievements.
- Differences in personality become reasons for hostility, suspicion and rivalry.
- Legitimate authority is mistaken for personal superiority, while legitimate accountability is dismissed as an infringement of personal freedom.
These attitudes undermine the very fraternity we profess. Respect is not necessarily agreement. We can disagree with a brother priest without disrespecting him, challenge an opinion without attacking the person, and question a decision without undermining the office of the one who made it. A priest should be mature enough to disagree without becoming disagreeable.
Priestly fraternity cannot thrive where every disagreement becomes a contest of personalities and every correction a battle for superiority.
5. The Declining Culture of Mentorship
The formation of a priest does not end with ordination. Seminary formation provides the foundation, but pastoral experience, the wisdom of senior confreres, spiritual direction, fraternal relationships and continuing formation are meant to deepen it. A newly ordained priest is not expected to know everything. He is expected to learn, observe, ask questions, seek guidance and gradually acquire the wisdom that responsible ministry demands.
Unfortunately, we sometimes meet the attitude that once a priest is ordained he no longer needs mentoring. Some younger priests are uncomfortable receiving guidance from older confreres, interpreting it as an attempt to control their decisions, restrict their freedom or remind them of their inexperience.
This is unfortunate, because mentorship is not an instrument of domination; it is an investment in another person’s growth. A mentor does not necessarily know everything, and a mentee is not necessarily lacking in intelligence or ability. Mentorship is the sharing of experience, insight and practical knowledge. There are things that cannot be learnt from books, degrees or lectures, but only through years of pastoral engagement, mistakes, disappointments, difficult assignments, human relationships and the demands of Church administration. An older priest who has walked that road has something valuable to offer.
Mentorship must also be exercised responsibly. Seniority does not confer infallibility. An older priest must be willing to listen, reconsider his assumptions and recognise the gifts of younger confreres. The relationship should be reciprocal in learning, though not identical in experience.
A wise priest does not compete with the younger generation; he helps to prepare it. A wise younger priest does not resent the experience of the older generation; he learns from it while bringing his own gifts to the ministry.
6. The Difficulty of Accepting Correction: A Crisis of Priestly Humility
Perhaps the most troubling aspect of the problem is the growing reluctance to accept correction. Correction is indispensable to Christian discipleship and priestly formation. No priest is above correction, because no priest is above human limitation. Celebrating the Eucharist, administering the sacraments, preaching the Gospel and exercising pastoral authority do not exempt us from growth and accountability.
Yet correction is often received as humiliation, advice as criticism, and legitimate questioning as disrespect. Why? Often because we have confused our priestly identity with our personal ego. When our sense of worth depends on being right, being recognised, being admired or having the final say, correction becomes threatening and we defend ourselves even when there is something to learn. Humility, by contrast, acknowledges that we can be wrong, that our judgement can be improved, and that another person may see what we have missed.
“God opposes the proud, but gives grace to the humble.” (James 4:6)
The priest who cannot accept correction may gradually become isolated within his own convictions, surrounded by people who affirm him rather than challenge him to grow. This is dangerous for both his spiritual life and his pastoral effectiveness.
We must, however, distinguish correction from humiliation. Correction should be truthful, proportionate and charitable, and directed towards improvement. It must never be used to embarrass, belittle or manipulate. The one who corrects must exercise charity; the one who is corrected must exercise humility. The ability to correct is a sign of responsibility; the ability to accept correction is a sign of maturity.
7. Insensitivity to Others: When Personal Preference Overrides Fraternal Consideration
Another mark of priestly immaturity is declining sensitivity to the feelings, expectations and legitimate concerns of others. Priesthood is not a private vocation lived in isolation. It is a public ecclesial ministry exercised within a community and governed by the teachings, traditions and disciplines of the Church. Personal preferences must therefore sometimes give way to the legitimate demands of our common life. This insensitivity may show itself in:
- Disregarding the feelings of fellow priests.
- Ignoring reasonable requests and established arrangements.
- Disregarding agreed rules and regulations.
- Showing little consideration for the responsibilities of others.
- Acting unilaterally where consultation and cooperation are expected.
- Interpreting every suggestion as an attempt to control personal freedom.
- Refusing to adjust behaviour even when it causes unnecessary discomfort or embarrassment to others.
The root is often an exaggerated sense of individual entitlement. We forget that we belong to a fraternity and that our conduct affects the wider community. Christian charity requires more than avoiding deliberate harm; it requires thoughtfulness and appreciation of others’ feelings. St Paul offers a helpful principle:
“All things are lawful, but not all things are beneficial.” (1 Corinthians 10:23)
Not everything we are personally comfortable doing is appropriate in every circumstance. Sensitivity is not weakness, and consideration is not subservience. Respecting another’s feelings does not mean surrendering one’s convictions; it means recognising that we do not live or minister alone.
8. Clerical Dress, Appearance and the Theology of Visible Witness
This lack of sensitivity and discipline becomes particularly evident in the matter of clerical dress and vestments. There is a growing tendency among some priests to treat established ecclesiastical regulations as optional suggestions, to be set aside whenever convenience or preference dictates.
Clerical attire is not merely a question of fashion or taste; it carries ecclesial, symbolic and pastoral significance. Canon 284 provides that clerics are to wear suitable ecclesiastical dress according to the norms of the Episcopal Conference and legitimate local custom. This is no invitation to vanity or obsession with externals. It recognises that the priest is a public representative of the Church, and that his appearance can communicate reverence, discipline, dignity and identification with his ministry.
The same applies to liturgical vestments. The alb, stole, chasuble, dalmatic and other prescribed garments are not personal fashion accessories; they have established meanings and norms, set out in the General Instruction of the Roman Missal. Compliance should not be resented as a restriction on individuality. The question should not only be, “What do I prefer to wear?” but also, “What does the Church prescribe, and what is fitting for this celebration?”
Even matters that seem minor, such as hairstyle, footwear and grooming, deserve thought. It is unnecessary to prescribe one hairstyle for every priest or to impose uniformity where the Church has not legislated. Nevertheless, personal grooming should reflect dignity, modesty, cleanliness and appropriateness, and footwear and general appearance should suit the occasion, the applicable diocesan guidelines and the dignity of the celebration. The concern is not whether a priest is fashionable, but whether he appreciates that his appearance and comportment are part of his public ministry.
We must avoid two extremes: reducing priestly identity to external appearance, and treating external discipline as though it had no relationship to our sacred calling. Our outward conduct should not contradict the values we proclaim. The priest does not own the priesthood; he receives it as a gift and exercises it within the communion and discipline of the Church.
9. Comportment in the Liturgy: The Priest Is a Servant of the Liturgy
More important than clerical dress is the manner in which priests conduct themselves during liturgical celebrations. The liturgy is not a personal performance, a social gathering or an occasion for self-expression. It is the public worship of the Church. Every priest taking part, whether as principal celebrant, concelebrant or assisting minister, is responsible for respecting the liturgical norms and contributing to the solemnity of the celebration. This involves:
- Maintaining reverence and recollection.
- Observing the prescribed gestures, postures and responses.
- Wearing the prescribed vestments.
- Respecting the roles of other ministers.
- Respecting the liturgical books and rubrics.
- Avoiding unnecessary movement, conversation and distraction.
- Avoiding unauthorised personal innovations.
- Showing discipline and cooperation throughout.
The Church’s liturgical law reminds us that no one, not even a priest, may on his own authority add, remove or change anything in the liturgy (Sacrosanctum Concilium, 22; GIRM, 24). The priest is a servant of the liturgy, not its owner. The altar is not a platform for the exhibition of individual preferences; it is the sacred place of the Church’s worship.
A priest who disregards liturgical discipline communicates something, consciously or not, about his understanding of the sacred. If we ask the faithful to observe silence, modesty, order and reverence in church, should we not model the same? We cannot teach the faithful to respect the liturgy while treating its regulations casually.
10. Academic Qualifications and Personal Achievements Do Not Replace Humility
The contemporary priest may have impressive academic qualifications, professional competence, international exposure and considerable intellectual achievement. These are valuable assets to the Church. But academic attainment must not be confused with spiritual maturity or pastoral wisdom. A doctorate does not automatically make a better priest. Years of service do not automatically make a wiser person. Holding office does not guarantee emotional maturity.
Every priest has something to learn and something to contribute. The danger begins when achievements become reasons to look down on others or to resist advice.
“Knowledge puffs up, but love builds up.” (1 Corinthians 8:1)
The measure of priestly maturity is not how much we know, how many degrees we hold, how influential we have become or how long we have been ordained, but how faithfully we reflect Christ in our relationships, decisions, responsibilities and service.
11. Recovering the Spirituality of the Presbyterium
The Second Vatican Council, in Presbyterorum Ordinis, teaches that priests are united by sacramental ordination and a common mission, and should therefore cultivate genuine fraternal relationships, mutual assistance and cooperation. This must move beyond ceremonial gatherings, anniversaries and occasional gestures of solidarity. Priestly fraternity must become a lived spirituality, visible in:
- How we speak to one another.
- How we handle disagreements.
- How we respond to mistakes.
- How we support struggling confreres.
- How we welcome the contributions of younger priests.
- How we mentor and guide one another.
- How we respect legitimate authority.
- How we observe ecclesiastical and liturgical discipline.
- How we accommodate differences in personality and experience.
We cannot preach reconciliation while harbouring bitterness against fellow priests. We cannot preach humility while refusing to acknowledge our own mistakes. We cannot teach obedience and respect while undermining legitimate authority in our own relationships. We cannot preach charity while fostering rivalry and division within the presbyterium. The credibility of our witness depends on the quality of our fraternity.
12. A Call to Recover a Culture of Priestly Maturity and Discipline
Perhaps it is time to recover, deliberately, certain values in our priestly relationships:
- Respect without intimidation. Every priest deserves respect, irrespective of age, appointment, qualification or social standing.
- Mentorship without domination. Older and more experienced priests should be available to guide younger confreres without imposing their personalities or preferences.
- Humility without insecurity. Younger priests should understand that receiving advice does not diminish their dignity, asking questions does not make them less intelligent, and accepting correction does not make them inferior.
- Authority without arrogance. Those entrusted with leadership should exercise it with patience, fairness, transparency and genuine concern for the growth of others.
- Correction without humiliation. We should be courageous enough to address inappropriate conduct and mistakes, yet charitable enough to preserve the dignity of the person concerned.
- Discipline without legalism. Ecclesiastical and liturgical norms should be respected, not out of obsession with rules, but because discipline promotes order, unity, reverence and the integrity of common worship.
- Sensitivity without pretence. We must consider how our words, actions, appearance and behaviour affect others.
- Freedom with responsibility. Personal preferences must be exercised within the legitimate boundaries of ecclesiastical discipline and the common good.
- Disagreement without hostility. We must create an environment where different opinions can be voiced without fear of victimisation or broken relationships.
- Fraternity without rivalry. Another priest’s success should not threaten us; his talents complement ours and his achievements enrich the Church.
13. Questions for Personal and Collective Examination
These questions are not meant to condemn anybody. They are invitations to examine ourselves honestly.
- Have we become so protective of our preferences that we have lost sensitivity to the feelings and legitimate expectations of others?
- Why do some priests find it difficult to accept established ecclesiastical norms that do not match their personal preferences?
- Can we teach the faithful obedience to the Church while showing reluctance to observe her own liturgical and disciplinary regulations?
- Have we confused priestly freedom with freedom from accountability?
- Why should a brother priest’s legitimate observation about our dress, conduct or liturgical comportment be read as an attempt to undermine our dignity?
- Have our years of ministry made us more teachable, or simply more accustomed to having our way?
- Are we willing to learn from younger priests, just as younger priests should learn from older confreres?
- Do we exercise authority to nurture and build others, or to intimidate and control them?
- Are we more concerned with defending our right to do what we want than with preserving the dignity, unity and credibility of the presbyterium?
- What example do we give the faithful when our own relationships are marked by disrespect, insensitivity and disregard for discipline?
14. Conclusion: Different in Experience, United in Mission
Yes, we are all priests, but we differ in age, experience, talents, hierarchy, responsibilities and personality. These differences should not become sources of division, resentment, arrogance or rivalry. They should become resources for mutual enrichment and for strengthening our common ministry.
The older should not despise the younger. The younger should not dismiss the older. The more experienced should not intimidate the less experienced, and the less experienced should not mistake confidence for competence or freedom for independence from legitimate accountability. We must rediscover the beauty of learning from one another.
There is no shame in being mentored, no indignity in receiving correction, no weakness in acknowledging a mistake, and no loss of dignity in listening to another’s experience. There is equally no justification for using seniority to humiliate, authority to intimidate, or rules to exercise unnecessary control over others.
The priesthood is not a private possession. It is a gift and a responsibility entrusted to us for the service of God’s people. We are not ordained to compete with one another but to complement one another; not to build personal empires but to build the Kingdom of God; not to know everything but to remain lifelong disciples of Christ.
A priest who refuses to be mentored may become a prisoner of his own limited experience. A priest who resents correction may grow blind to his own weaknesses. A priest who disregards the feelings of others may undermine the fraternity he professes to cherish. And a priest who treats ecclesiastical discipline as optional may lose sight of the fact that his ministry is exercised within the Church, not independently of her.
Perhaps the greatest testimony to the maturity of a presbyterium is not the number of priests it produces, the degrees its members acquire or the positions they hold, but its capacity to nurture men who respect one another, learn from one another, correct one another in charity and remain united in the service of Christ and His Church.
We are all priests, but none of us is the complete embodiment of priestly wisdom. We need one another.
A Final Thought: Priesthood, Humility and Accountability
Priesthood gives us a common identity; humility gives that identity its beauty.
Age should teach us patience, experience should teach us wisdom, hierarchy should teach us responsibility, talent should teach us service, and personality differences should teach us tolerance.
Our freedom should not make us insensitive, our experience should not make us arrogant, our authority should not make us domineering, and our ordination should not make us unteachable.
The true test of priestly maturity is not simply how we celebrate the Eucharist, but also how we respect one another, how we conduct ourselves, how we observe the discipline of the Church and how willing we remain to be corrected.
May the Lord who called us into His service give us the humility to learn, the wisdom to guide, the courage to correct, the grace to accept correction, the sensitivity to consider others and the charity to remain brothers.
Amen.
Fr. Kunle Dukiya
Note for Sharing with Fellow Priests
This reflection is not an indictment of younger priests, older priests or any particular group within the presbyterium. It is a call to collective self-examination. Every priest, regardless of age, experience, appointment or academic attainment, has something to learn and something to contribute.
The purpose is not to police one another, but to help us recover the spirituality, discipline and mutual respect that should characterise our common priesthood. We are brothers in the priesthood. Let us learn to behave like brothers, respect one another as brothers, correct one another as brothers and remain accountable to the Church whose ministers we are.
Ecclesiastical and Scriptural References
For further reflection and discussion:
- Second Vatican Council, Presbyterorum Ordinis (1965), especially nos. 7–9: priestly communion, fraternity and mutual assistance.
- Second Vatican Council, Sacrosanctum Concilium (1963), especially nos. 22 and 26: regulation and ecclesial nature of the liturgy.
- Code of Canon Law, can. 273: reverence and obedience owed by clerics to ecclesiastical authority.
- Code of Canon Law, can. 284: ecclesiastical dress.
- Code of Canon Law, can. 392: the bishop’s responsibility to safeguard ecclesiastical discipline.
- General Instruction of the Roman Missal, nos. 24 and 335–347: liturgical regulation and sacred vestments.
- James 4:6: humility.
- 1 Corinthians 10:23: freedom and the common good.
- 1 Corinthians 8:1: knowledge and charity.
- Matthew 20:26–28: authority as service.



Comments
No comments yet. Be the first to respond.